Sunday, April 8, 2012

Non-Ontological Existence

Does Love exist?
Does Order exist?
Does Light exist?
Does 'science' exist?
Does Peace exist?
Does thought exist?
Do YOU exist?

Nine out of ten people on the streets will answer "yes" to the questions posed above.
But...if you ask
'Does GOD exist? and Does RELIGION exist?,'
they'll say it does not.
They’ll say 'God is created by humans and so is religion. It is an illusion.'
To declare you are atheist has become the 'in' thing. Even within spiritual circles they talk about ‘no religion.’ ‘All are one. We all belong to one religion called LOVE.’
The Marxist criticism on religion goes like this:
"Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people."
My question being, Is opium all that bad?
No, seriously. Is it? You can ask a certain Samuel Taylor Coleridge about it.
What does a religion do? Religion promotes love, peace, togetherness, compassion, faith, devotion, surrender, satisfaction, happiness, bliss. That's the very nature of human being - which every individual is striving to attain. Then why is there so much spoken against religions? It has always intrigued me as to why people miss to see the beauty in religion. It is almost shocking. It could be true that I speak with a certain religious ideological influence. But spare some time and hear me out in the series of articles that I'll come up with over the course of time. I'm not trying to force my ideologies on you. I'm only trying to show you various possibilities in case you haven't thought of it already. At the end of it all, each her own way :)

People think it's ridiculous to talk about religion in the present day context. And I think it’s ridiculous not to talk of it. When one cannot understand or comprehend a certain phenomena, they become repulsive. The anger or fear is simply due to the unknown. Metaphysics is a field that tries to explain the inexplicable. Kant says that religion is based on morality. I disagree. I’m not denying that morality is a part of religion. However, that’s not the basis of it. For me, religion is a perfect balance of transcendence and realism. Kant also talks about something called rational metaphysics. It may sound absurd at first as it did to me. I assume that's what religion is. Religion tries to explain and understand what we cannot and in the journey we discover and experience 'Godness'.

A general opinion is that to follow a religion is to follow the crowd. But that is not true. If you consider Dvaita philosophy of religion, the very crux of it talks about individuality. Sri Madhwacharya has said that there's duality not only between jeevatma and paramatma but between all souls. He says that each person is unique and enlightenment is achieved through individual consciousness.

Religious rituals, 'atheists' say, are nothing more than dogmas. They are followed in blind faith. One of the rituals we Hindus follow is to sing to the Lord. There's a story that I was told as a kid which explains why God lives where there's music. Let's not get to that story. But I'll narrate a real-life story. There's this boy I saw. He is about 12 years old now. He never had the gift of speech. Physically handicapped at birth. He has no IQ or EQ is what the doctors told. There was no hope left for the little boy. One day, this boy was left on his own in a room for a few minutes and there was a record playing. The record was 'dasara padagaLu' sung by Sri Mysore Ramchandrachar. The boy gained speech and now expresses emotions. He cannot read or write. He knows more than a hundred devotional songs by heart. The doctors have no idea how that happened. It is a miracle. Let’s say it - God's grace! I'm sure all of you have seen at least one such miracle in front of your own eyes. How do you explain that? What is it if not proof for God's existence?
Oh by the way, Kant in his Critique of Judgement says: 'Those who have recommended the singing of spiritual songs as part of the family prayers did not consider how great a discomfort they impose on their audience with this noisy and hence usually Pharisaical worship, because they force their neighbours either to sing along or to interrupt their intellectual labours.'
The Western world is so caught up in the so called world of knowledge that they don't have time for wisdom.
Coming back to rituals. One, there are things that are scientific and hence made part of a religious doctrine. For example, going to the temple is considered auspicious because temples are supposed to be built along the grid of the Earth. They are energy centers of the planet. To visit a place full of positive energy increases your healthy aura. The ringing of the bells and the shlokas chanted add on to the atmosphere. Two, shlokas are arranged in a scientific manner. It doesn't matter even if one doesnt know the actual meaning of a shloka, it'll still prove effective. As Kant himself says (I might have taken this out of context), the 'immediate experience' leads to 'super-sensible reality.' Perform the rituals and then see for yourself whether or not you are in an elevated state of consciousness.

In the next article I'll try to cover more topics in greater detail.

'Don't be so open-minded that your brains fall out.' - Richard Dawkins

8 comments:

Aviral Shrivastava said...

well written....though the arguments that you give are still not convincing...esp regarding the energy around the temples, the chanting of shlokas, the rituals etc...the temples are still "supposed" to be place of energy..but are they???
religion i believe, is a concept to make people do good, in the name of some supreme being... because otherwise for their fellow beings they won't do it...
and if someone is conscious enough to do good to others without bringing God in between...i don't think he needs religion....
religion helps in bringing order in society...people may tend to follow rules or be ethical/moral in the name of religion which otherwise they probably won't
I guess Marx was talking about religion being opium in this sense....

yes...we blindly follow rituals... do people even know why they do what they do???? just because it's told by some pundit and written in some holy text book... that is no reason to follow it...
this is a nice read
http://www.marxists.org/archive/bhagat-singh/1930/10/05.htm
i'm not asking anyone to be an atheist... just raising my doubts...
dubito ergo cogito, cogito ergo sum :)
...

Aviral Shrivastava said...

i haven't read much on these topics...but I would recommend to read the essays of Shashi Tharoor in Elephant Tiger and Cellphone on hinduism..i found them good ..

Shruthi said...

dubito ergo cogito, cogito ergo sum. That's the Western way of going about everything i guess.
that's what we have brought it all down to. doubts. doubts. doubts. Questioning is a good thing. But lack of faith does no good. Because, like they say, the eye of faith can see much that is hidden from the vision of the non-believer.
you are right, today we hardly know what the significance of certain rituals are...but if you follow them the way it is supposed to be done, it'll surely reap benefits. Energy follows thought. right? :)

This article might have not been convincing enough. I intend to take it deeper in the future.
thank you for the comment and thank you for the suggestions. I'll read them up :)

Aviral Shrivastava said...

well...just one thing...say there is a common hardworking man who does not know much... who hasn't read holy scriptures etc...neither has the time or energy to do so... and he has his doubts regarding religion... can anybody explain it to him in layman language why religion is important... why should he follow a particular path... i guess if it is explained in simpler terms, which appeals to his simple mind and makes him understand the importance... religion would make a lot of sense... miracles, cosmic energy, rituals etc should not be the reason to follow a religion...peace of mind, wisdom etc should be enough i guess...can religion give me that?????
i don't know how it can be done...just a thought

Sharmada said...

I was wondering... Whatever anyone says or however convincing their argument might be laid out before you, at the end of the day, you choose to believe (either taking cognizance of the fact or by sub-conscious means) in a particular set of ideas or beliefs or not, based on your sense of qualia. And these are condensed out of your life experiences which are fairly unique to you.

chiragchinnappa said...

Great thought, the truth is that we normally tend to make sense of stuff think that we can understand all that is happening without really knowing what is really happening within us. to tend to make sense out of the smallest and simplest beauties of this life by distorting them. without experimentation and experience we cannot comment on anything, this is what i tend to see these days, making sense in a way i would never understand.

Lakshmeesha K said...

"Religion promotes love, peace, togetherness, compassion, faith, devotion, surrender, satisfaction, happiness, bliss"- GEM!

Shruthi said...

Leia Mais, you are right. opinions cannot be forced down the throat.

Chinnappa, true, it's all about what you can make of it than what already is...

Lakshmeesha, :)
there are many things that i have written here to which i don't agree anymore! :D